Is a police officer liable when they cause a motor vehicle accident in Iowa?

Iowa City, IA – There were local news reports that a police officer was involved in a crash that injured others in the Pleasant Hill area [1].

Two injured during crash caused by police officer

In Pleasant Hill, Iowa, a serious crash occurred on the evening of August 2, 2024, involving Davis County Sheriff David Davis and a Des Moines man, Travis Pinegar, and his 4-year-old grandson. Pinegar and his grandson were stopped at a red light on East University Avenue when they were rear-ended by Davis, who was driving a 2008 Ford F-250 at 45 mph. The impact pushed Pinegar’s vehicle, a 2023 Dodge Charger, into the intersection, resulting in a secondary collision with another car turning onto NE 56th Street.

Pinegar sustained significant injuries, including a fractured skull, brain bleed, and concussion. He is expected to remain hospitalized for several weeks. His grandson, Junior, also suffered serious injuries but was released from the hospital the following day. Pinegar’s seatbelt and the child’s car seat are credited with saving their lives.

Sheriff Davis, 61, admitted to causing the crash and was cited for following too closely and failing to obey a traffic light. The Pleasant Hill police report indicated that Davis was fatigued and did not notice the red light. There were no signs of impairment at the scene. Davis made several statements acknowledging his fault but declined to comment further when approached by the media.

Police officer liability for accidents

In Iowa, as in many states, a police officer can be held liable for causing a motor vehicle accident under certain circumstances. Generally, police officers are granted certain legal protections while performing their official duties, such as “qualified immunity,” which shields them from liability for actions taken in the course of their duties if those actions are deemed reasonable.

However, this immunity does not extend to all scenarios. If an officer’s conduct is negligent or reckless, such as failing to obey traffic laws when not engaged in an emergency response, they may be held liable. In Iowa, the legal principle of “negligence” requires proving that the officer breached a duty of care owed to others on the road, causing damages or injuries as a result.

For instance, if a police officer disregards traffic signals or is excessively speeding without an emergency justification, and this behavior leads to a crash, the officer can be held responsible. The key factors in determining liability include whether the officer’s actions were within the scope of their official duties and whether they were reasonable under the circumstances.

In cases where an officer is involved in an accident while responding to an emergency, the analysis of liability may be more complex. Courts often apply a higher standard of reasonableness to determine if the officer’s actions were appropriate given the urgency of the situation. Nonetheless, if the officer’s conduct is deemed grossly negligent or reckless, they may face liability despite the emergency context.

In summary, while police officers in Iowa have some legal protections when performing their duties, they can be held liable for accidents caused by negligent or reckless behavior, especially when they violate traffic laws or fail to act within the bounds of their official responsibilities.

Accident attorneys in Iowa

Eells and Tronvold Law Offices is a firm that handles accident and personal injury cases for clients throughout the state of Iowa.

USAttorneys.com is available to provide legal referrals to anyone who calls 800-672-3103 for assistance.

Firm contact info:

Eells and Tronvold Law Offices

1921 51st Street NE, Cedar Rapids, IA 52402-2400

319-393-1020

www.eellsandtronvold.com

Sources: